The $7.3 Million Auction of the Redfield Silver Dollar Hoard

January 27 • American Coin History Calendar

When eccentric Nevada investor LaVere Redfield died, his estate contained one of the greatest accumulations of silver dollars ever discovered: hundreds of thousands of Morgan and Peace dollars, many still packed in original Mint bags. On January 27, 1976, a probate-court auction sold the hoard intact for $7.3 million. The winning bid transformed a lifetime of secretive saving into a landmark numismatic event and sent “Redfield dollars” into collections across America.

A Fortune Hidden Behind a Wall

LaVere Redfield did not assemble his silver dollars like a conventional numismatist filling albums by date and mint mark.

He accumulated them in bulk.

For years, bags of silver dollars were reportedly brought to his Reno, Nevada home and stored in a concealed area behind a wall in the basement. By the time his holdings were inventoried after his death in 1974, the quantity was staggering.

Accounts of the Redfield estate commonly place the total at more than 400,000 silver dollars, overwhelmingly Morgan dollars with a smaller number of Peace dollars.

The estate's silver dollars were offered intact through a probate-court auction on January 27, 1976.

Rather than selling individual rarities one coin at a time, the court offered an enormous numismatic accumulation as a single lot.

The winning price was $7.3 million.

The buyer was the A-Mark Coin Company of Los Angeles.

At the time, the transaction was one of the most spectacular coin purchases the hobby had ever seen.

Redfield was born in Utah in 1897 and eventually settled in Nevada.

He built wealth through investments, real estate and the stock market while cultivating a reputation for extreme frugality.

Stories about him emphasize an almost contradictory lifestyle: a wealthy investor who could appear remarkably unconcerned with displaying wealth.

That personality is part of what makes the hoard memorable. Redfield accumulated a multimillion-dollar mountain of coins while living far less flamboyantly than the collection might suggest.

Why Silver Dollars?

Redfield lived in exactly the right place and era to accumulate them.

Large quantities of Morgan dollars remained available in the western United States long after the coins had largely vanished from routine use elsewhere.

Nevada casinos and banks had practical reasons to handle silver dollars. The coins were familiar in gaming, and bags could move through regional financial channels.

Redfield reportedly acquired bags at face value whenever opportunities arose, treating silver dollars as both hard money and a store of wealth.

Modern collectors may imagine Redfield carefully checking each coin for a Carson City mint mark or rare date.

That was not the basic strategy.

His accumulation was famous for scale, not meticulous date-by-date selection.

He acquired bags and kept them.

This distinction matters because the hoard's numismatic importance came partly from what decades of bulk storage accidentally preserved: large groups of original, uncirculated silver dollars that had never been dispersed through ordinary circulation.

The Morgan dollar was struck from 1878 through 1904 and again in 1921.

Designed by George T. Morgan, it carries a portrait of Liberty on the obverse and an eagle within a wreath on the reverse.

Millions were produced under silver-purchasing laws that required the federal government to buy enormous quantities of domestic silver.

Many of those dollars were not actually needed in commerce. They sat for decades in Treasury and bank vaults.

The Morgan dollar is unusual because production and public demand were often disconnected.

Congressional silver policy helped drive mintages even when Americans preferred paper currency for ordinary transactions.

Bags containing 1,000 silver dollars could remain untouched for decades.

When those bags eventually entered the market, they sometimes contained coins that were many decades old but still technically uncirculated.

Redfield's hoard was one dramatic example of this phenomenon.

The hoard also contained Peace dollars, the successor to the Morgan series.

Anthony de Francisci's Peace dollar debuted in 1921 and was produced through 1935, with the principal original production years concentrated in the 1920s.

Its youthful Liberty and perched eagle symbolized the nation's desire for peace after World War I.

Although Redfield's name is most strongly associated with Morgans, the presence of Peace dollars broadened the hoard's importance.

Reno Was Silver-Dollar Country

Nevada occupies a special place in American silver-dollar history.

The Comstock Lode had helped transform the nation's silver economy in the nineteenth century. The Carson City Mint struck some of the most celebrated Morgan dollars. Casinos later kept large dollar coins useful in everyday regional commerce long after they became unusual elsewhere.

Redfield's accumulation was therefore not a random hoard that happened to be found in Nevada.

It grew in a state deeply connected to silver mining, silver coinage and dollar circulation.

The words “Nevada silver-dollar hoard” naturally make collectors think of Carson City.

Yet the Redfield hoard should not be confused with the famous Treasury dispersals of Carson City dollars sold by the General Services Administration in the 1970s.

Redfield's holdings were a private accumulation built through years of acquisition.

Its contents included many dates and mints, with large quantities from San Francisco among the most notable groups.

Long-term bag storage can create remarkable Mint State survivors, but it does not guarantee pristine surfaces.

A standard bag of 1,000 Morgan dollars weighs well over fifty pounds.

Coins collide with one another during filling, movement and storage. Their reeded edges can strike neighboring surfaces, producing the contact marks collectors call “bag marks.”

A coin can therefore be completely uncirculated yet show numerous marks from other coins.

Silver reacts with its environment over time.

Decades in canvas bags and storage conditions can produce toning ranging from light gold to deep blues, reds, purples and darker colors.

Some Redfield dollars developed distinctive peripheral or multicolored toning.

Today, attractive original toning can command substantial collector interest, although toning varies enormously from coin to coin and unattractive dark surfaces are also possible.

The romance of a huge untouched hoard can create the impression that every coin inside must have been spectacular.

That was not the case.

The accumulation included a wide range of quality. Some coins were heavily bag-marked, weakly struck, toned unattractively or otherwise ordinary.

Others were exceptionally appealing.

The task after the auction was to sort an immense volume of material and determine which pieces deserved special attention.

Winning the auction was only the beginning.

A-Mark now had to secure, transport, inventory, sort, grade, market and distribute hundreds of thousands of heavy silver coins.

The physical mass alone was extraordinary. A Morgan dollar weighs about 26.73 grams. Hundreds of thousands of them amount to many tons of metal.

The $7.3 million purchase was therefore both an investment and a massive operational undertaking.

The Average Acquisition Cost Was Surprisingly Modest

Dividing $7.3 million by a little over 400,000 coins produces an average cost in the neighborhood of the high teens per coin, though the precise figure depends on which total count is used.

That does not mean every dollar was worth the same amount.

A bulk purchase contains a distribution of dates, mints, conditions and market values.

But the rough calculation helps explain the economics: A-Mark was betting that sorting and retailing the hoard could unlock substantially more value than the estate received in one wholesale transaction.

The Redfield dollars were ultimately marketed to collectors through Paramount International Coin Corporation.

Many were placed in distinctive plastic holders identifying them as part of the Redfield collection.

Those holders became nearly as recognizable as the story itself.

Decades later, an original Redfield holder can provide an important provenance link between an individual coin and the famous Nevada hoard.

Before today's dominant third-party grading services standardized tamper-evident numerical-grade holders, dealers and marketers often created their own packaging.

The Redfield dispersal occurred in that earlier era.

Original holders commonly use the Redfield name prominently and may describe a coin with broad quality language rather than a modern certified grade.

Collectors should therefore evaluate the coin itself rather than treating vintage holder wording as equivalent to current third-party grading.

Two otherwise similar Morgan dollars can attract different levels of interest if one has documented Redfield provenance.

The reason is historical, not metallic.

A traceable Redfield dollar connects its owner to one of the largest private silver-dollar accumulations ever dispersed.

This is a good example of provenance becoming a collectible attribute in its own right.

The story travels with the coin.

Because the Redfield name is desirable, collectors should not accept unsupported claims casually.

An original recognized Redfield holder provides strong evidence. Modern grading-service labels may also preserve recognized provenance when the coin's chain of custody was established during submission.

A loose raw Morgan dollar accompanied only by a seller's statement that it “came from Redfield” is a different matter.

Hoard pedigree is most useful when documentation survives.

Some Dates Became Closely Associated With the Hoard

The Redfield accumulation contained large groups of certain Morgan dollar dates, especially western issues.

Its dispersal affected the market by bringing quantities of Mint State coins into collector channels at once.

For specialists, hoards can reshape perceptions of rarity. A date once considered difficult in uncirculated condition may become more available when a long-hidden group appears.

This is one reason silver-dollar rarity cannot be understood from original mintage alone.

A Morgan dollar might have a large original mintage but be scarce today if most examples circulated or were melted.

Another date with a similar mintage may be common in Mint State because bags survived in Treasury vaults or private hoards.

The Redfield story demonstrates how survival history can be just as important as production history.

Collectors are buying what survived, not what existed on the day of striking.

The timing of the 1976 auction is important.

During the 1960s, enormous quantities of old silver dollars had already emerged from Treasury storage as collectors and dealers exchanged paper money for coins at face value.

Then, in the 1970s, the federal government sold remaining Carson City dollars through the General Services Administration.

By the time Redfield's private hoard reached the market, public enthusiasm for Morgan dollars was already intense.

The 1970s were a volatile period for precious metals.

Silver prices rose dramatically later in the decade, culminating in the extraordinary 1979–1980 spike associated with the Hunt brothers' attempt to dominate the silver market.

Redfield dollars therefore entered collector hands just before silver itself became a national financial story.

Common silver dollars carried both numismatic value and a substantial precious-metal component.

A Morgan or Peace dollar contains approximately 0.7734 troy ounce of silver when measured by its original standard.

Once silver's market value rose sufficiently, the metal alone was worth more than the one-dollar denomination stamped on the coin.

That made it economically irrational for old silver dollars to circulate at face value.

By 1976, the era when Redfield could simply accumulate bags as ordinary money was already gone.

Redfield's Timing Was Extraordinary

Redfield had accumulated his coins when silver dollars could still be obtained through ordinary banking channels at face value.

He died after the United States had removed silver from most circulating coinage and after collectors had begun aggressively searching for surviving silver dollars.

His estate therefore inherited a stockpile acquired under one monetary system and sold under another.

The $7.3 million auction price captured that transformation.

If the coins had been valued only for silver, the Redfield story would be much less interesting.

The collection contained dates, mint marks, varieties, high-grade pieces and original surfaces worth premiums far beyond melt value.

The challenge for the buyers was separating ordinary bullion-related value from true numismatic value.

That sorting process converted a mountain of silver into hundreds of thousands of individual collectibles.

A major hoard can alter a market quickly.

If collectors believe only a few hundred Mint State examples of a date exist and thousands suddenly emerge, scarcity assumptions must change.

Prices may fall or fail to rise as expected.

Conversely, an unusually high-quality group can reveal that superb examples exist while ordinary examples remain common.

Hoard history is therefore part of serious population analysis.

Large private hoards fascinate collectors because they create a sense of hidden history.

For years, enormous numismatic value can exist behind a wall, in a vault, under a floor or inside forgotten bank storage without affecting the public market.

Only when the coins emerge does the market learn that the supply it thought it understood was incomplete.

Redfield's basement became one of the most dramatic examples of that phenomenon.

Redfield's life also included well-publicized thefts and security concerns.

Accounts of his holdings describe burglars stealing large sums from his property years before his death.

Those experiences help explain the secretive storage associated with the surviving hoard.

The concealed basement cache was not simply eccentricity; storing physical wealth creates obvious security risks.

A sealed or long-undisturbed hoard can preserve more than coins.

It preserves patterns of banking, saving and monetary behavior.

Redfield's bags reflected a time when a person in Nevada could acquire large silver dollars through financial channels at face value and consider them a practical form of savings.

That world disappeared when silver coins vanished from circulation.

The hoard survived as physical evidence of it.

Why Collectors Still Talk About Redfield

The hobby has seen larger government stockpiles and spectacular individual rarities, but the Redfield hoard occupies a special middle ground.

It was private rather than governmental, enormous rather than individually curated, and filled with coins that ordinary collectors could eventually own.

A Redfield dollar does not have to be a six-figure rarity to carry a famous pedigree.

That accessibility helped keep the story alive.

The headline price should be understood in its own time.

Seven million dollars in the mid-1970s represented vastly greater purchasing power than the same nominal amount today.

The court was not disposing of a modest coin collection. It was liquidating a major financial asset.

The auction demonstrated that numismatic holdings could reach institutional-scale values when accumulated in sufficient quantity.

The original accumulation no longer exists as a single mountain of silver.

It was broken apart, sorted and distributed decades ago.

Yet thousands of individual coins continue to carry the Redfield name in collections and auction catalogs.

Each documented example is a fragment of a once-hidden Nevada cache.

In that sense, the dispersal destroyed the hoard as a physical unit but expanded its cultural reach.

On January 27, 1976, LaVere Redfield's extraordinary silver-dollar hoard crossed from private accumulation into numismatic history.

A probate-court auction sold more than 400,000 Morgan and Peace dollars intact for $7.3 million to A-Mark Coin Company.

The sale turned decades of secretive saving into one of the most famous hoard dispersals in American coin collecting.

It also illustrated a fundamental truth of numismatics: the supply of old coins is shaped not only by how many were minted, but by what people saved, what governments stored, what was melted—and what may still be hidden away.

Redfield's basement had preserved a piece of the silver-dollar era long after that era had vanished from everyday American money.

Interested in this classic American coin? Shop handcrafted Morgan Silver Dollar coin rings from CoinCrafters, made from authentic coinage and finished by hand.

• The Law That Brought the Morgan and Peace Dollars Back
• A Construction Crew Unearths the New Orleans Silver Coin Hoard
• Two Baltimore Teenagers Unearth 3,558 U.S. Gold Coins
• Morgan and Peace Silver Dollars Return After a One-Year Pause