MARCH 15
1933•25,000 1933 Double Eagles Delivered at Philadelphia Mint
2018•Breast Cancer Awareness Commemorative Coins
The First 25,000 1933 Double Eagles Are Formally Delivered Inside the Philadelphia Mint
On March 15, 1933, the Philadelphia Mint recorded the first formal delivery of 25,000 newly struck 1933 Saint-Gaudens $20 gold pieces from the Coiner to the Mint Cashier. The coins had begun being struck earlier in March, but this internal transfer created an accounting milestone that would become enormously important decades later. Because no 1933 double eagles were officially released into ordinary circulation, investigators, collectors and federal courts would eventually scrutinize the Mint's delivery records, cashier accounts and exchange procedures to determine how a handful of the legendary coins escaped destruction.
◆
The 1933 Double Eagle story is usually told through one coin.
The Farouk coin.
The only example that the United States government has formally monetized for private ownership.
But before there could be a famous survivor, there had to be 445,500 ordinary pieces sitting inside the Philadelphia Mint.
And before those coins could be tracked, they had to enter the Mint's books.
March 15 Was an Accounting Event
The first 1933 double eagles had already been struck.
March 15 did not mark the beginning of production.
Instead, it marked the first documented delivery of finished coins from one Mint officer to another.
The quantity was 25,000 pieces.
Historic Mint operations divided responsibility among officers.
The Coiner's department manufactured coins.
Once accepted and accounted for, finished pieces could be formally transferred into the custody of the Mint Cashier.
That movement mattered because it changed who was responsible for the government's gold.
At face value, the March 15 delivery represented:
25,000 × $20 = $500,000.
That was half a million dollars in official United States gold coin.
Yet the coins were not being shipped to banks or released to the public.
They were moving internally.
Numismatic dates can become confusing because “made,” “struck,” “delivered” and “issued” do not mean the same thing.
A coin can be struck by a press and still remain within the manufacturing department.
It can then be delivered into another Mint account.
It can remain in government custody without ever being issued into circulation.
The United States Mint unquestionably manufactured hundreds of thousands of 1933 double eagles.
The controversy concerns what happened afterward.
Were any lawfully paid out?
Could one have been legitimately exchanged?
Or did every privately held example leave government custody without authorization?
Saint-Gaudens' Masterpiece
The coin itself was one of America's most celebrated designs.
Sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens created the double eagle at the urging of President Theodore Roosevelt.
Production began in 1907.
The obverse shows Liberty striding forward with a torch and olive branch.
The reverse shows an eagle in flight above the rising sun.
The earliest 1907 pieces were produced in extremely high relief and proved impractical for mass coinage.
Relief was reduced.
In 1908, the motto IN GOD WE TRUST was added after congressional action.
By 1933, the design had been a standard American gold coin for more than a quarter century.
The United States was in the depths of the Great Depression.
Bank failures had shaken confidence.
Gold was leaving financial institutions as people sought security in specie.
President Franklin D. Roosevelt took office on March 4, 1933 and immediately confronted a banking emergency.
Roosevelt proclaimed a national banking holiday shortly after his inauguration.
The federal government moved rapidly to stabilize banks and control gold flows.
That policy environment is crucial to understanding why newly minted $20 gold pieces never entered ordinary circulation.
The Mint still had institutional responsibilities and gold-accounting requirements.
So double eagles dated 1933 were manufactured even while national gold policy was changing around them.
The result was a coin produced in quantity but effectively trapped inside the Mint.
Philadelphia ultimately produced 445,500 1933 double eagles.
That number sounds enormous compared with the tiny number known today.
It is one of the great lessons in numismatics: mintage and survival can be radically different.
The first 25,000-piece transfer was followed by additional deliveries.
As production continued, the Mint's internal records tracked hundreds of thousands of pieces.
Those records later allowed investigators to reconstruct the official population with unusual precision.
Gold coin was government property.
Every ounce mattered.
Mint officers had to account for bullion received, metal in process, finished coin, wastage and transfers.
The accounting system was designed to prevent exactly the kind of unexplained disappearance that later made the 1933 double eagle famous.
A Mint employee could not simply take a newly struck double eagle home.
A $20 coin represented substantial monetary value.
Removing one without lawful payment or authorization would create a shortage in an accountable government fund.
The Cashier's Account Becomes Central
Once coins were delivered to the Cashier, their movement could be compared against cashier records.
Later legal arguments examined whether a 1933 double eagle might have been exchanged for an older $20 gold piece in an ordinary transaction.
The internal books became evidence.
Not every 1933 double eagle was destroyed.
Two examples were transferred to the Smithsonian Institution for the National Numismatic Collection.
Those pieces are unquestionably legitimate government-preserved specimens.
Other examples that surfaced outside federal custody created a problem.
If they had never been officially issued, how had they escaped?
That question would eventually involve the Secret Service, dealers, collectors, a king, international diplomacy and federal courts.
Philadelphia coin dealer Israel Switt became the central private figure in the story.
Multiple 1933 double eagles that surfaced in the 1940s were traced back to him.
Switt had business connections around the Philadelphia Mint and dealt extensively in gold coins.
Mint Cashier George McCann also became central to federal suspicions.
Investigators believed that coins could have left the Mint through an improper exchange involving the Cashier's office.
The exact mechanics of how the surviving coins escaped have remained the subject of debate.
One theory held that 1933 coins could have been substituted for older double eagles of the same face value.
If $20 went out and another $20 came in, the account could still balance numerically.
That possibility made physical coin identity important even when dollar totals matched.
Imagine an older $20 gold piece entering the account while a 1933 $20 piece left.
The books could still show twenty dollars on each side.
The monetary total would balance.
But the government's specific 1933 coin would be gone.
Accounting systems designed primarily to track value do not always track individual coin dates and die characteristics.
A double eagle was legally twenty dollars regardless of whether it was dated 1928 or 1933.
Collectors care intensely about that difference.
An accountant might not—unless the coin was never authorized for release.
By the 1940s, 1933 double eagles had appeared in the numismatic market.
The United States Secret Service investigated.
Several examples were recovered from collectors and dealers.
The government maintained that the coins had been stolen or unlawfully removed from the Mint.
Recovered Coins Were Destroyed
Most of the recovered privately held 1933 double eagles were eventually melted.
That destruction further reduced the surviving population.
The Smithsonian examples remained.
One other coin had taken a very different path.
In 1944, an example was sold to King Farouk of Egypt, an enthusiastic collector.
Before the coin left the United States, an export license was issued for it.
That bureaucratic approval became one of the strangest twists in the entire saga.
By the time authorities recognized the problem, the coin was already in Farouk's collection.
The United States sought its return.
It did not immediately come back.
King Farouk was deposed in 1952.
His vast collections were prepared for auction.
The 1933 double eagle appeared in the catalog.
After the United States objected, it was withdrawn.
For decades, the Farouk 1933 double eagle vanished from public view.
Collectors knew it had existed.
The government knew it had existed.
But its location was unknown.
The coin resurfaced in New York in 1996.
British dealer Stephen Fenton brought a 1933 double eagle to the United States for a potential sale.
Federal agents seized it during an operation at the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel.
The coin's history and identifying evidence supported the conclusion that it was the example once owned by King Farouk.
That mattered because of the old export license.
The case was no longer simply about an undocumented 1933 double eagle.
It involved a coin the government itself had once permitted to leave the country.
After years of litigation, the government and Fenton reached a settlement.
The coin would be sold at public auction.
Proceeds would be divided.
Most unusually, the United States agreed to monetize the coin.
Before the 2002 auction, the Mint formally issued the coin and accepted payment of its $20 face value.
That act gave it a unique legal status.
The coin became the only 1933 double eagle that the government has expressly authorized for private ownership.
Sotheby's and Stack's sold the coin in New York on July 30, 2002.
The final price was $7,590,020, including the additional $20 used to monetize it.
At the time, it set a world auction record for a coin.
The Extra Twenty Dollars Was the Most Important Twenty Dollars
Against a multimillion-dollar price, $20 seems meaningless.
Legally, it was crucial.
It symbolized the government's formal issuance of a coin that had spent nearly seventy years at the center of an argument about whether it had ever been lawfully issued.
The story became even more remarkable in 2004.
After Israel Switt's daughter Joan Langbord and her family examined a safe-deposit box associated with him, they discovered ten 1933 double eagles.
Finding one 1933 double eagle would be extraordinary.
Finding ten transformed the legal and numismatic landscape.
The family turned the coins over to the Mint for authentication.
The Mint authenticated them—and retained them.
The family challenged the government's claim to the coins.
Years of litigation followed.
The dispute addressed forfeiture procedure, ownership and the historical evidence surrounding the 1933 issue.
This is where events such as the March 15 delivery became far more than clerical trivia.
Attorneys and judges examined Mint records to determine what had been produced, delivered, destroyed, transferred and potentially removed.
Documents created for ordinary government accounting in 1933 became evidence in twenty-first-century federal litigation.
After extensive proceedings and appeals, the government retained the ten Langbord coins.
They remain United States property.
They are not lawful private collectibles like the monetized Farouk-Fenton example.
The legally privately owned 1933 double eagle returned to auction in June 2021.
It came from the collection of designer Stuart Weitzman.
Sotheby's sold it for $18,872,250.
The contrast is almost absurd.
Its face value is $20.
Its gold content gives it substantial bullion value.
Its historical and legal uniqueness pushed its collector value into another universe.
Many rare coins are valuable because few were struck.
The 1933 double eagle is almost the opposite.
Hundreds of thousands were struck.
Its rarity exists because almost all were withheld and destroyed.
This makes the coin a perfect lesson in survival rates.
Mintage tells us how many pieces were manufactured.
It does not tell us how many entered circulation.
It does not tell us how many escaped melting.
It does not tell us how many can legally be owned.
Three Different Populations
For the 1933 double eagle, collectors must think about at least three numbers:
- how many were struck;
- how many physically survive;
- how many are legally available for private ownership.
Those are radically different quantities.
The Smithsonian coins survive.
The Langbord coins survive.
The monetized Farouk-Fenton-Weitzman coin survives.
But only the last of those categories is privately collectible under the government's position.
A first delivery establishes a point in the custody chain.
Twenty-five thousand finished 1933 double eagles moved from the Coiner's responsibility into the Cashier's account.
That is exactly the kind of documentary milestone investigators need when reconstructing how a coin could have left the Mint.
The concept is familiar from criminal evidence.
Who possessed the object?
When did possession change?
Was the transfer documented?
For gold coins worth half a million dollars at face value, the Mint had its own institutional chain of custody.
Nearly all the 1933 double eagles were melted.
The paper trail survived.
That reversal is striking.
Physical objects disappeared while administrative records became the durable evidence of their existence.
Collectors often romanticize coins and ignore paperwork.
Yet some of the most important facts in numismatics come from ledgers, delivery records, correspondence, assay documents and cashier accounts.
Without those records, the 1933 story would be much harder to reconstruct.
The 1933 double eagle is visually almost identical to earlier Saint-Gaudens pieces.
Its extraordinary status comes from date and history.
The metal alone cannot explain why one example is worth millions while a common-date Saint-Gaudens double eagle is not.
Documents create context.
The 1933 double eagle represents a monetary system at the moment it changed.
Gold coin had been a foundational part of American money for generations.
Then federal policy sharply restricted private monetary gold holdings and removed gold coin from ordinary domestic circulation.
1933 became the final date of the classic Saint-Gaudens double eagle.
The denomination did not return to ordinary circulating coinage.
Modern American Eagle bullion coins would later revive Saint-Gaudens' Liberty design, but in a fundamentally different monetary context.
On April 5, 1933, President Roosevelt issued Executive Order 6102 restricting private hoarding of monetary gold and requiring much of it to be delivered to the government, subject to exemptions.
That order came after the March 15 internal Mint delivery.
The chronology matters.
The Gold Reserve Act
In January 1934, the Gold Reserve Act further transformed American gold policy.
Gold held by the Federal Reserve was transferred to the Treasury.
The dollar's official gold valuation was subsequently changed.
The old world of circulating domestic gold coin was effectively over.
It was manufactured under the machinery of the old gold-coin system.
It was withheld under the emerging new system.
That makes the coin a monetary transition captured in metal.
The first 1933 double eagles were struck earlier in March.
March 15 records something different: the first formal delivery of 25,000 finished pieces from the Coiner to the Cashier.
One date is about manufacture.
The other is about custody and accounting.
If we care only about when a press first struck the design, March 15 seems administrative.
If we care about the later ownership controversy, March 15 becomes essential.
The entire legal saga turns on what happened to coins after they were made.
That paradox has sustained fascination for generations.
The Mint made nearly half a million.
The public was not supposed to receive them.
A few escaped.
The government spent decades recovering them.
One eventually became legal to own.
Behind the glamour of a multimillion-dollar rarity was a government accounting system.
Gold came in.
Coins were struck.
Coins were delivered.
Coins were held.
Coins were destroyed.
The mystery exists in the tiny difference between what the records say should have remained and what physically escaped.
On March 15, 1933, 25,000 new double eagles crossed an internal institutional line.
They became the first formal delivery of the year's $20 gold pieces from the Coiner to the Mint Cashier.
At the time, it was routine accounting.
Decades later, records of such transfers would help define one of the greatest ownership disputes in numismatic history.
On March 15, 1933, the Philadelphia Mint formally delivered its first 25,000 1933 Saint-Gaudens double eagles from the Coiner to the Cashier—a half-million dollars in newly struck gold coin that would never enter ordinary circulation. The transfer became part of the documentary trail later used to reconstruct how a handful of 1933 double eagles escaped destruction. In the story of America's most famous gold rarity, the paperwork became almost as important as the coin.
ALSO ON THIS DAY
2018 — Breast Cancer Awareness Commemorative Coins — The Mint opened sales for the Breast Cancer Awareness commemorative coin program, including the nation's first pink-hued gold coin.